2011 -- The Year To Trash Hubble!
A flurry of papers and followup blog articles have appeared recently
pointing out that it was Lemaitre, not Hubble, who first obtained a value
for the "Hubble" constant, and thus arguing that it is Lemaitre who should
be given credit for discovery of the expanding universe. Here is a list
of recent postings:
- arXiv:1104.3031
M. J. Way & H. Nussbaumer, "The linear redshift-distance relationship:
Lemaitre beats Hubble by two years"
- arXiv:1105.6271
J.P. Luminet, "Editorial note to 'The beginning of the world from the
point of view of quantum theory'"
- arXiv:1106.1195
S. Van Den Bergh, "The Curious Case of Lemaitre's Equation No. 24"
- arXiv:1106.3928
D. Block, "A Hubble Eclipse: Lemaitre and Censorship"
- arXiv:1107.0442
G. Shaviv, "Did Edwin Hubble plagiarize?"
- arXiv:1107.2281
H. Nussbaumer & L. Bieri, "Who discovered the expanding universe?"
- arXiv:1108.0709
S. Van Den Bergh, "Discovery of the Expansion of the Universe"
-
Nature News E. S. Reich, "Edwin Hubble in translation trouble"
- Nature News E. S. Reich,
"Letter sheds light on alleged censorship by Hubble"
- Forbes
J. Farrell, "Why Hubble's Law ... Wasn't Really Hubble's"
-
Nature M. Livio, "Lost in translation: Mystery of the missing text solved"
Everyone seems to have forgotten that the topic was aired back in 2007.
- arXiv:0704.3579
J.-P. Luminet, "The Rise of Big Bang Models, from Myth to Theory and
Observations"
- Discovery
S. Carroll, "Update: Lemaitre vs. Hubble"
A new round of Trash Hubble papers has appeared, from the Sept 2012
Symposium "Origins of the Expanding Universe: 1912-1932"
- arXiv:1301.7286
J. Peacock, "Slipher, galaxies, and cosmological velocity fields"
- arXiv:1301.7294
M. Way, "Dismantling Hubble's Legacy?"
- arXiv:1212.5499
C. O Raifeartaigh, "The contribution of VM Slipher to the discovery of the
expanding universe" [This paper actually has a good perspective on the
Lemaitre paper.]